Fast Losing Ground

I’m writing a series of posts summarizing my position on the Intelligence Explosion, and here I want to give a couple of examples of recent AI developments which should make even hardened skeptics consider the possibility that our creations might soon catch up with us.

But first, I want to point out that while the history of early AI research is marred by over-confident prognostications that wound up not panning out and causing several “AI winters”, it is also true that AI skeptics have a history of believing that ‘machines will never do X’, only to have machines do X not very long thereafter.

This is humorously captured in the following cartoon, attributed to Ray Kurzwiel:



Most of us are rapidly becoming acquainted with living in a world suffused with increasingly smart software. But many would be surprised to learn that there are computer programs in existence now which can write compelling classical music. Emily Howell is the product of several decades work by David Cope, who conceived of the idea of creating software to help with his music after experiencing a particularly bad case of composer’s block. The results speak for themselves:


Granted this is not exactly breathtaking; it might be what we’d expect from an advanced piano student who was still primarily leaning on technique because she hadn’t found her creative voice yet. But it’s a long way from the soundtracks of 8-bit video games I grew up playing, and it was written by a computer program.

But what about natural language? Computer-generated music is impressive, but can computers rise to the challenge of processing and responding to speech in real time? IBM’s Watson, a truly monumental achievement, managed to not only do this, but to utterly stomp two of the best jeopardy players of all time. Last I checked the technology was being turned to helping doctors perform better diagnoses.

In my mind the most impressive example is the lesser-well-known Adam (King et al., 2004), an almost fully autonomous science laboratory which, when fed data on yeast genetics, managed to form a hypothesis, design and carry out an experiment to test its hypothesis, and in the process discover something that was unknown to any scientist before. Though this may seem like light-years away from an AI doing, say, astrophysics research, the difference is one of degree, not kind.

Admittedly, we’re still not talking about general intelligences like human beings here. But the weight of the evidence points to a future where increasingly large chunks of civilization are being managed by intelligent machines. This may come to include the production of art, science, and even the design of new intelligent systems.


One thought on “Fast Losing Ground

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s